Xenotheka
Xenotheka
  • Home
  • Collaboration
  • On Xenotheka
  • Folders
  • Categories
    • _English Language
    • _French Language
    • _German Language
    • _Italian Language
    • Architectural Theory
    • Architecture and Literature, Symbolism
    • Architecture + Philosophy
    • Artists in Rome
    • Art Theory
    • Bernini
    • Christian Iconography
    • France
    • Empire, Architecture + Catholicism
    • Italy
    • Literary Theory
    • Historiography
    • Low Countries (Benelux)
    • Modern
    • Monuments + Conservation
    • Portrait, Sculpture, Materiality
    • Popes, Vatican, Rome
    • Post-Modern
    • Renaissance
    • Rome
    • Sources
    • 17th Century
    • 1750-1850
    • 20th Century
    • 21th Century
  • ask.alice-ch3n81
  • _English Language
  • medieval library

Abelard, Ethics

  • By: Xenotheka
  • December 29, 2020
  • 0
  • 2
  • 7

 

Abelard takes the rational core of traditional Christian morality to be radically intentionalist, based on the following principle: the agent’s intention alone determines the moral worth of an action. His main argument against the moral relevance of consequences turns on what has been called “moral luck.” Suppose two men each have the money and the intention to establish shelters for the poor, but one is robbed before he can act whereas the second is able to carry out his intention. According to Abelard, to think that there is a moral difference between them is to hold that “the richer men were the better they could become … this is the height of insanity!” Deed-centred morality loses any kind of purchase on what might have been the case. Likewise, it cannot offer any ground for taking the epistemic status of the agent into account, although most people would admit that ignorance can morally exculpate an agent. Abelard makes the point with the following example: imagine the case of fraternal twins, brother and sister, who are separated at birth and each kept in complete ignorance of even the existence of the other; as adults they meet, fall in love, are legally married and have sexual intercourse. Technically this is incest, but Abelard finds no fault in either to lay blame.

 

 

Download

Abelard_Ethics.pdf
Abelard_Ethics.txt
Abelard_Ethics.html
Abelard_Ethics.jpg
Abelard_Ethics.zip

 

 

  • Tags
  • abelard
  • Ethics
  • moral
  • pierre
← Previous Article
Pye, The Nature and Art of Workmanship
→ Next Article
Abelard, The Letters to Heloise and other Writings

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recently added books

Duncan, The James Bond Archives

Duncan, The James Bond Archives

January 11, 2021
An, Roman, 10 Creation Myths

An, Roman, 10 Creation Myths

January 11, 2021
Mack, The Sea: A Cultural History

Mack, The Sea: A Cultural History

January 6, 2021
Mirrlees, Collected Poems

Mirrlees, Collected Poems

January 6, 2021
Mitchell, Daoist Nei Gong: The Philosophical Art of Change

Mitchell, Daoist Nei Gong: The Philosophical Art of Change

January 6, 2021

Categories

  • _English Language 961
  • _French Language 53
  • _German Language 65
  • _Italian Language 53
  • _Latin Language 42
  • 1750-1850 64
  • 17th Century 76
  • 17th culture and other cities in Italy 5
  • 19th century 45
  • 20th Century 150
  • 21th Century 75
  • Ancient Literature 36
  • Architectural Theory 216
  • Architecture + Philosophy 28
  • Architecture and Literature, Symbolism 29
  • Art 6
  • Art Theory 96
  • Artificial Intelligence 1
  • Artists in Rome 20
  • Autobiography 1
  • Bernini 19
  • Catalogue 1
  • Christian Iconography 18
  • Christianity 7
  • Cinema 1
  • City 44
  • Design 29
  • Digital Architectonics 13
  • Drawings 39
  • Economy 13
  • Empire, Architecture + Catholicism 13
  • England & British Isles 23
  • Evolution 2
  • Fashion 5
  • Feminism 11
  • Film Festival 1
  • France 43
  • Gender and Sexuality Studies 4
  • Gothic 13
  • Greek, Roman Library 62
  • Historiography 31
  • Humanism 10
  • India 5
  • Italy 76
  • Landscape Architecture 8
  • LGBT 1
  • Libraries 0
  • Linguistics 1
  • Literary Criticism 2
  • Literary Theory 62
  • Literature 53
  • Low Countries (Benelux) 14
  • Mathematics 32
  • Medicine 1
  • medieval library 32
  • medieval literature 7
  • Modern 48
  • Monuments + Conservation 27
  • Mythology 13
  • Philosophy 210
  • Physics 11
  • Politics 46
  • Popes, Vatican, Rome 27
  • Portrait, Sculpture, Materiality 56
  • Post-Modern 21
  • Programming 1
  • Psychology 14
  • Religion 2
  • Renaissance 77
  • Roman Architecture 19
  • Rome 118
  • Schinkel 8
  • Science 35
  • Sociology 12
  • Sources 56
  • Spain 10
  • Switzerland 47
  • Uncategorized 67
  • Urbanism 52

Follow Us

Most liked books

Duncan, The James Bond Archives

Duncan, The James Bond Archives

January 11, 2021
An, Roman, 10 Creation Myths

An, Roman, 10 Creation Myths

January 11, 2021

Recent Comments

     

    Categories

    • _English Language 961
    • _French Language 53
    • _German Language 65
    • _Italian Language 53
    • _Latin Language 42
    • 1750-1850 64
    • 17th Century 76
    • 17th culture and other cities in Italy 5
    • 19th century 45
    • 20th Century 150
    • 21th Century 75
    • Ancient Literature 36
    • Architectural Theory 216
    • Architecture + Philosophy 28
    • Architecture and Literature, Symbolism 29
    • Art 6
    • Art Theory 96
    • Artificial Intelligence 1
    • Artists in Rome 20
    • Autobiography 1
    • Bernini 19
    • Catalogue 1
    • Christian Iconography 18
    • Christianity 7
    • Cinema 1
    • City 44
    • Design 29
    • Digital Architectonics 13
    • Drawings 39
    • Economy 13
    • Empire, Architecture + Catholicism 13
    • England & British Isles 23
    • Evolution 2
    • Fashion 5
    • Feminism 11
    • Film Festival 1
    • France 43
    • Gender and Sexuality Studies 4
    • Gothic 13
    • Greek, Roman Library 62
    • Historiography 31
    • Humanism 10
    • India 5
    • Italy 76
    • Landscape Architecture 8
    • LGBT 1
    • Libraries 0
    • Linguistics 1
    • Literary Criticism 2
    • Literary Theory 62
    • Literature 53
    • Low Countries (Benelux) 14
    • Mathematics 32
    • Medicine 1
    • medieval library 32
    • medieval literature 7
    • Modern 48
    • Monuments + Conservation 27
    • Mythology 13
    • Philosophy 210
    • Physics 11
    • Politics 46
    • Popes, Vatican, Rome 27
    • Portrait, Sculpture, Materiality 56
    • Post-Modern 21
    • Programming 1
    • Psychology 14
    • Religion 2
    • Renaissance 77
    • Roman Architecture 19
    • Rome 118
    • Schinkel 8
    • Science 35
    • Sociology 12
    • Sources 56
    • Spain 10
    • Switzerland 47
    • Uncategorized 67
    • Urbanism 52
    • Home
    • Collaboration
    • On Xenotheka
    • Folders
    • Categories
    • ask.alice-ch3n81

    Copyright © Xenotheka